Main Content

Home » Cindy Pagnotta

Cindy Pagnotta

Cindy Pagnotta
Sales Associate/CEO
Listing & Buyer Specialist

Long a highly successful Realtor, Cindy Pagnotta serves her clientele with progressive systems and strategies while working within a Company that matches her passion for doing business ‘the right way’.  By joining Sotheby’s International Realty, Cindy is pleased to bring her 16 years of professional real estate expertise to exponentially enhance international networking opportunities to the advantage of her real estate clients.  Cindy’s clients are thrilled. They discover that luxury is not just about price — it’s also about the quality of service, marketing, and personal attention throughout the buying and selling process that Cindy delivers. Her Client-Centric business philosophy provides a small team approach to ensure clients have access to all information, options and area expertise, allowing buyers and sellers to feel completely confident.  Cindy strives to deliver an outstanding service experience to her clients by using all of her efforts to exceed their expectations before, during and after the transaction.  In return, her clients, service providers and friends enthusiastically refer their family members, friends, neighbors and co-workers to her for any aspect of the real estate process.  Cindy continues to earn the respect and trust of clients and colleagues alike while earning top awards for her distinguished sales record and superlative customer service.

A New Jersey native, Cindy formerly resided in Union County and with her family and has been a resident of Bridgewater since 2001.  Beginning her real estate career in 2004 with one of the nation’s largest real estate firms, Cindy rose to the top 1% of the Company’s agents nationwide as early as 2006. Specializing in Somerset, Hunterdon, Morris and Union Counties, Cindy markets homes in all price ranges; from town homes to luxury properties. Cindy provides a successful state-of-the-art marketing plan and a long track record of sold listings to home sellers. Her area expertise, experience, and commitment to her clients are the foundation for her effective and strategic negotiation skills.   Her Testimonials from homeowners speak of her expert knowledge, gracious interpersonal abilities and driven dedication. Cindy’s ability to inspire trust in clients and fellow agents allows her to pair buyers and sellers before homes even reach the market.  Cindy enjoys spending time with her family when not working.


  • Top 1% of Agents Nationwide
  • International Presidents Elite Award
  • NJ Realtors Circle of Excellence Sales Award 2006-2019; Platinum Level 2011-2015
  • NJ Realtors Distinguished Sales Award 2016 (Recipient of the NJ Realtors Circle of Excellence Sales Award for 10 Years)
  • 2016-2019 NJ Five Star Real Estate Agent Award (as seen in NJ Monthly)
  • Top Producer in her Office 2006-2019
  • #1 Agent in Bridgewater/Martinsville out of all Realtors for listings sold, buyer-controlled sales and total sales volume 2008-2015


  • National Association of Realtors® (NAR)
  • New Jersey Association of Realtors® (NJAR)
  • North Central Jersey Association of Realtors® (NCJAR)
  • Garden State Multiple Listing Service (GSMLS)