Main Content

Where to Find the Best Pizza in Somerville, NJ

pizza

Best known for its charming Victorian and row homes, history-rich Somerville is one of the most desirable places to live in Central Jersey. The borough also boasts a thriving downtown, where gourmet dining destinations abound.

With Main Street’s generous selection of restaurants, however, it can be easy to feel spoiled for choice. In times like these, beat the confusion with a classic favorite – pizza.

Here are 5 names to remember when you want to get the best pizzas in Somerville:

  1. Famous Alfonso’s Family Trattoria & Gourmet Pizza
    99-101 West Main Street, Somerville, NJ 08876
    908-526-0616

    Alfonso’s Trattoria first opened its doors in 1978 in Somerville’s historic downtown. The restaurant has since built a loyal following with its specialty pizzas and various other authentic Italian pasta, pork, chicken, and seafood dishes. It’s hard to run out of choices here, thanks to various specials and offers scheduled throughout the week. Alfonso’s even offers a gluten-free menu that guarantees guilt-free indulgence for the health-conscious.

  2. Prima Pizza
    131 North Gaston Avenue, Somerville, NJ 08876
    908-203-1800 or 01

    Prima Pizza guarantees oven-fresh pizzas made as you order them. In addition to its delectable pies, this eatery also serves pasta, calzones, cold subs, steak sandwiches, and wraps. Appetizers range from mozzarella sticks to spicy chicken wings, while zesty Italian soups and fresh salads round out the impressive menu.

  3. Central Pizzeria
    126 West Main Street, Somerville, NJ 08876
    908-722-8272

    Serving fine Italian fare in a cozy, casual setting since 1955, Central Pizzeria is a Main Street staple beloved among generations of Somerville residents. In addition to a satisfying variety of traditional and gourmet pies, Central also delights the palate with al forno pastas and breads, steaks, and seafood dishes. Guests can choose from an extensive selection of wines, cocktails, beers, and other specialty drinks.

  4. Vinnie’s II Pizzeria & Restaurant
    131 North Gaston Avenue, Somerville, NJ 08876
    908-704-8822

    Not all of Somerville’s best pizzerias are huddled along Main Street. Just 5 minutes away from the downtown district is a hidden gem known as Vinnie’s, where dishes come in generous servings and at the most reasonable prices. Check out this low-profile eatery and see for yourself how it has earned a reputation for serving some of the best pizzas, parmigiana dishes, and strombolis in town.

  5. Calabria Mia Pizzeria & Gelateria
    83 West Main Street, Somerville, NJ 08876
    908.436.7947

    For your fix of pizzas, paninis, and homemade gelato, you can’t go wrong with Calabria Mia. A memorable dining experience awaits as Italian cooking combines seamlessly with the venue’s warm and casual vibe, designed to evoke the genuine feel of Italy’s southern Calabria region. After your meal, stop by next door for an espresso at its sister café, the Café Picasso.

There’s more than great eats in Somerville, NJ. Explore this website for some of the borough’s fantastic housing options. Or you can get in touch with Cindy Pagnotta and her team of Central Jersey real estate specialists. They also specialize in homes in other exceptional Somerset County neighborhoods like Bridgewater, Martinsville, Basking Ridge, Bedminster, and Warren.

Join Our Network

Please fill out this form and we will be in touch shortly.

    *Required Field